Sicily’s Best Menu

Sicily’s Best Menu

House Favorites

White Pizza$24.75
A delicious pizza topped with creamy ricotta cheese over a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Broccoli Sauteed with Garlic Pizza$25.75
Sautéed broccoli on a regular pizza base.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Vegetable Pizza$25.75
A medley of broccoli, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives on a regular pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza$27.00
A unique pizza topped with grilled chicken Caesar salad on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs

---

Caprese Pizza$27.00
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, basil, olive oil, and grated cheese on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Pizzas

Plain Cheese Pizza$20.00
Classic cheese pizza or create your own.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Grandma Pizza$22.50
A traditional pizza with a rich tomato sauce and mozzarella.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicilian Pizza$22.50
Thick crust pizza with a hearty tomato sauce and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Supreme Sicilian Pizza$31.50
Topped with chicken cutlet and tomato sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicily’s Best Special Sicilian Pizza$30.25
A hearty pizza with pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Margherita Sicilian Pizza$29.25
Fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and tomato sauce on a thick crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Gluten Free Pizza$13.50
A gluten-free Neapolitan pizza option.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten-Free

---

Gluten Free Margherita Pizza$16.75
A gluten-free version of the classic Margherita pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten-Free, Dairy

---

Buffalo Chicken Pizza$27.00
Spicy chicken on a thin crust pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

BBQ Chicken Pizza$27.00
Barbecue chicken on a thin crust pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Supreme Pizza$27.00
Chicken cutlet with tomato sauce on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Hawaiian Pizza$24.75
A sweet and savoury combination of ham and pineapple on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken with Fresh Tomato Pizza$27.00
Chicken cutlets topped with diced tomatoes on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Grilled Chicken Salad Pizza$27.00
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions on a thin crust pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicily’s Best Special Pizza$27.00
A hearty pizza with pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and black olives.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Lasagna Pizza$27.00
Chopped meat and ricotta cheese on a regular pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Baked Ziti Pizza$24.75
Baked ziti served on a thin crust pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Vodka Pizza$27.00
Topped with a creamy vodka sauce on a thin crust.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Salad Pizza$24.75
A garden salad served on a thin crust pizza with Italian dressing on the side.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Family Specials

#1 Family Meal Special$35.75
Includes a large cheese pie, baked ziti, meatball parmigiana hero, and 6 garlic knots.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

#2 Family Meal Special$54.75
Includes a large cheese pie, baked ziti, chicken parmigiana hero, 6 pepperoni bites, 6 garlic knots, buffalo wings, and a 1.25-liter soda.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs

---

#3 Family Meal Special$34.75
Includes a large cheese pie, baked lasagna with meatballs, 6 knots, and 6 bites.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs

---

Everyday Specials

Everyday Special$23.50
Includes a large pie, 6 garlic knots, and a 1.25-liter soda.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicily’s Specials

Cheese Tortellini alla Vodka$15.75
Tortellini served with a creamy vodka sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Tortellini Alfredo$15.75
Tortellini served with a rich creamy Alfredo sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Lasagna, Eggplant Rollatini, & Veal Parmigiana$17.50
A combination of lasagna, eggplant rollatini, and veal parmigiana.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Fruitta di Mare$51.50
Serves 2 people. A seafood medley of shrimp, clams, mussels, and calamari over pasta.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Papa Joe’s Special$12.25
Spaghetti or ziti with garlic and oil and fresh crushed tomato.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Pizza by the Slice

Cheese Pizza Slice$3.50
A slice of classic cheese pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicilian Pizza Slice$3.50
A slice of thick Sicilian pizza.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken & Tomato Pizza Slice$5.25
A slice topped with chicken and fresh tomatoes.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice$5.25
Spicy chicken mixed with blue cheese on a slice.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cream of Spinach Pizza Slice$5.25
A slice topped with creamy spinach.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

White Pizza Slice$5.25
A slice with ricotta cheese, grated cheese, salt, and pepper.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Margarita Pizza Slice$5.25
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil on a slice.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicilian Margarita Pizza Slice$5.25
A thick slice with fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and extra virgin olive oil.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Appetizers

French Fries$5.00
Crispy golden fries.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Pepperoni Bites$3.75
Delicious bites of pepperoni.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Buffalo Wings$13.50
10 pieces of wings, available regular or spicy.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Side of Meatballs$8.50
A side of homemade meatballs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Side of Sausage$8.50
A side of Italian sausage.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Garlic Knots$3.00
Soft knots of dough baked with garlic and butter.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Garlic Bread$3.75
Toasted bread with garlic and butter.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Garlic Bread Parm$4.75
Garlic bread topped with melted parmesan cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sauteed Broccoli$7.75
Fresh broccoli sautéed to perfection.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Fried Calamari$13.50
Crispy fried calamari served with marinara sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Mozzarella Sticks$11.25
Breaded mozzarella cheese sticks, fried until golden.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Jamaican Beef Patty$4.00
A flaky pastry filled with seasoned beef.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten

---

Side of Sauce$1.75
A side of marinara or garlic sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Side of Dressing$1.75
A side of your choice of dressing.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Soups

Chicken Noodle Soup$7.25
A comforting bowl of chicken noodle soup.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Minestrone Soup$7.25
A hearty vegetable soup with pasta.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Lentil Soup$7.25
A nutritious lentil soup packed with flavour.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Salads

Caesar Salad$7.75
Crisp romaine lettuce with Caesar dressing and croutons.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs

---

Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken$14.75
A Caesar salad topped with grilled chicken.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Eggs

---

Antipasto Salad$9.50
A mix of cured meats, cheeses, and olives.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

House Salad$7.75
A fresh garden salad with a variety of vegetables.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

California Salad$16.25
Romaine lettuce topped with diced chicken, tomatoes, onions, shredded mozzarella, and black olives.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Homemade Rolls & Calzones

Chicken Roll$8.00
Breaded chicken strips topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Eggplant Roll$8.00
Breaded eggplant rolled and baked with cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Sausage Roll$8.00
Italian sausage rolled in dough and baked.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cheese Calzone$8.75
A folded pizza filled with cheese and baked to perfection.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Hot & Cold Heros

Buffalo Chicken Hero$9.00
A hero sandwich filled with spicy buffalo chicken.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Buffalo Chicken Parmigiana Hero$10.50
Buffalo chicken topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Veal & Peppers Hero$11.00
Tender veal with peppers in a hero sandwich.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Veal & Peppers Parmigiana Hero$12.25
Veal and peppers topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Veal Cutlet Hero$10.00
A hero filled with tender veal cutlet.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero$11.50
Veal cutlet topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Cutlet Hero$9.00
A hero filled with crispy chicken cutlet.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero$10.50
Chicken cutlet topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Meatball Hero$8.50
A hero filled with homemade meatballs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Meatball Parmigiana Hero$9.25
Meatballs topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Eggplant Hero$8.50
A hero filled with breaded eggplant.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero$9.25
Eggplant topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sausage Hero$8.50
A hero filled with Italian sausage.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sausage Parmigiana Hero$9.25
Sausage topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sausage & Peppers Hero$8.75
Sausage and peppers in a hero sandwich.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana Hero$10.00
Sausage and peppers topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Philly Cheese Steak Hero$9.50
A hero filled with steak, onions, and peppers.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Peppers & Egg Hero$7.75
A hero filled with peppers and eggs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs

---

Peppers & Egg Parmigiana Hero$9.25
Peppers and eggs topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs, Dairy

---

Potatoes & Eggs Hero$7.75
A hero filled with potatoes and eggs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs

---

Potatoes & Eggs Parmigiana Hero$9.25
Potatoes and eggs topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs, Dairy

---

Shrimp Hero$10.75
A hero filled with shrimp and toppings.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero$12.00
Shrimp topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish, Dairy

---

Sausage & Egg Hero$8.50
A hero filled with sausage and eggs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs, Dairy

---

Sausage & Egg Parmigiana Hero$9.75
Sausage and eggs topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Eggs, Dairy

---

Grilled Chicken Hero$9.50
A hero filled with grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Grilled Chicken Parm Hero$11.00
Grilled chicken topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cold Chicken Cutlet Hero$9.50
A cold hero filled with chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, and dressing.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cold Chicken Cutlet Parm Hero$11.00
Cold chicken cutlet topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Grilled Chicken Hero with Fresh Mozzarella$10.00
Grilled chicken with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and dressing in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Grilled Chicken Parm Hero with Fresh Mozzarella$11.50
Grilled chicken topped with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and dressing in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cold Italian Hero$9.00
A cold hero filled with ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and dressing.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cold Italian Parm Hero$10.50
Cold Italian meats topped with marinara and cheese in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

GodFather Hero$11.00
Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, oregano, olive oil, and balsamic vinegar in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

GodFather Parm Hero$12.25
GodFather hero topped with marinara and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Cutlet Alla Vodka Parm Hero with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese$13.00
Chicken cutlet with vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Cutlet Alla Vodka Parm Hero$11.50
Chicken cutlet with vodka sauce in a hero.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Homemade Burgers

Hamburger$9.00
A classic hamburger served with lettuce and tomato.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten

---

Deluxe Hamburger$12.00
A deluxe hamburger served with lettuce, tomato, and French fries.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten

---

Cheeseburger$10.00
A cheeseburger served with lettuce and tomato.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Deluxe Cheeseburger$13.00
A deluxe cheeseburger served with lettuce, tomato, and French fries.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Paninis

Bushwick Panini$10.00
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, and balsamic vinegar in a panini.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicily’s Best Panini$10.00
Ham, grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella with mayo or extra virgin olive oil in a panini.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Ridgewood Panini$10.00
A simple panini with extra virgin olive oil.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Forget About It Panini$11.75
Prosciutto, pepperoni, provolone cheese, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, and balsamic vinegar in a panini.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Baked Dinners

Homemade Lasagna$13.50
Layers of pasta, meat, and cheese baked to perfection.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Baked Ziti$12.25
Ziti pasta baked with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Cheese Ravioli$12.25
Ravioli filled with cheese and baked with sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Baked Tortellini$12.25
Tortellini baked with cheese and sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Stuffed Shells$12.25
Large pasta shells stuffed with cheese and baked with sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sicily’s Best Combination Dinners

Veal Parmigiana Combination Dinner$17.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Chicken Parmigiana Combination Dinner$16.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Meatballs Combination Dinner$14.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Sausage Combination Dinner$14.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Eggplant Parmigiana Combination Dinner$14.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Shrimp Parmigiana Combination Dinner$19.75
Served with your choice of lasagna, baked ziti, stuffed shells, or ravioli.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Shellfish

---

Dinners

Pasta with Homemade Marinara Sauce$11.00
Pasta served with a rich homemade marinara sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce$9.75
Pasta served with a classic homemade tomato sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Pasta with Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner$16.75
Pasta served with a veal cutlet topped with marinara and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Pasta with Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner$15.75
Pasta served with a chicken cutlet topped with marinara and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Pasta with Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner$14.00
Pasta served with eggplant topped with marinara and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Vegan

---

Pasta with Sausage$13.00
Pasta topped with Italian sausage.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Pasta with Clams Dinner$14.50
Pasta served with clams in your choice of red or white sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Pasta with Garlic & Oil$11.25
Pasta tossed in extra virgin olive oil and garlic.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Pasta with Homemade Meatballs$13.00
Pasta served with homemade meatballs.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Pasta with Calamari Marinara Dinner$18.00
Pasta served with calamari in marinara sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Pasta with Fried Calamari Dinner$18.00
Pasta served with fried calamari.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Pasta with Broccoli Dinner$13.50
Pasta served with broccoli in garlic and oil or marinara sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Vegan

---

Pasta with Bolognese Sauce$15.75
Pasta served with a rich bolognese sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Entrees

Fettuccine Alfredo$13.50
Fettuccine pasta served with a creamy Alfredo sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken$17.50
Fettuccine Alfredo topped with grilled chicken.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp$20.00
Fettuccine Alfredo topped with shrimp.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Shellfish

---

Shrimp Marinara over Pasta$20.00
Shrimp served over pasta with marinara sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Shrimp Fra Diavolo over Pasta$20.00
Spicy shrimp served over pasta.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Shrimp Scampi over Pasta$19.25
Shrimp sautéed in garlic and butter served over pasta.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish

---

Shrimp Parmigiana$19.25
Shrimp topped with marinara and cheese.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Shellfish, Dairy

---

Penne Alla Vodka$13.50
Penne pasta served with a creamy vodka sauce.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Penne Alla Vodka with Grilled Chicken$17.50
Penne alla vodka topped with grilled chicken.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Penne Alla Vodka with Shrimp$19.25
Penne alla vodka topped with shrimp.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy, Shellfish

---

Penne Alla Romana$14.50
Penne pasta with chopped tomatoes, garlic, basil, and melted mozzarella.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Penne Broccoli with Garlic, Olives & Grilled Chicken$18.00
Penne pasta with broccoli, garlic, olives, and grilled chicken.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Gluten, Dairy

---

Beverages

Apple Juice$3.50
Refreshing apple juice.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Orange Juice$3.50
Freshly squeezed orange juice.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Ocean Spray$3.50
A refreshing cranberry drink.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Snapple$3.50
A variety of refreshing Snapple drinks.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Water$2.00
Bottled water.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Soda$2.00
A variety of sodas available.
Dietary/Allergen Info: Vegan

---

Most restaurants charge a small cover charge (~$1–3 per person)

Categories: American, Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian

Menu Source: Restaurant Website PDF

Menu Date: August, 2025